RANsquawk G10 Central Bank Monitor – 10 November 2017
SourceNewsquawk
SectionMarket Analysis
CLICK HERE TO DOWNLOAD THE FULL REPORT AS A PDF
- FED: A hawkish tilt in 2018 might not be on the cards
- ECB: Unlikely to be concerned by EUR until it hits 1.20
- BOE: Inflation to peak?
- BOJ: Time for Kuroda to say sayounara?
- SNB: On repeat
- BOC: Awaiting Poloz and Wilkins’ speeches
- RBA: Inflation likely to remain low for some time
- RBNZ: Hawkish hold
- Norges Bank: Is the Norges Bank likely to revise up its inflation forecasts?
- Riksbank: Undershooting inflation worse than an overshoot
NOTE: YOU CAN RECEIVE THIS ANALYSIS AS AN EMAIL BY USING THIS LINK
FEDERAL RESERVE
- With only one meeting remaining in 2017 (12-13 December, where a rate hike is more than fully priced in; according to the CME’s Fedwatch tool, there is a 91.5% chance rates will be lifted by 25bps to between 1.25% and 1.50%, and an 8.5% chance rates will be hiked to between 1.50% and 1.75%), the focus is now shifting onto the 2018 voting configuration.
- Assuming that Jerome Powell will be confirmed as Chairman on 28 November, and assuming that Janet Yellen will relinquish her role on the FOMC once her term as Chair concludes, it means that there are three vacancies on the Board of Governors. And then there are the regional Federal Reserve Banks: NY Fed’s Dudley (permanent voter) is due to step down from his position in the middle of 2018, there is also a vacancy for the position of Richmond Fed President, which is on the voting rotation for 2018. The other 2018 voters are the hawkish Loretta Mester, a presumed dovish Rafael Bostic of the Atlanta Fed, and the moderate John Williams of San Francisco.
- “The turnover is happening at the Board of Governors and regional Fed Presidents,” Oxford Economics writes. “While this does not equate to a large change in the expected gradual pace of rate hikes, the rotation raises the possibility that the pace of hikes could be on the high end of what could be considered a gradual removal of policy accommodation.”
- It presents US President Trump with a significant opportunity to shape the Fed. “The new Governors could swing more hawkish in their views of monetary policy and favour a roll back of some of the post-financial crisis regulation,” OxEco says; but with that said, the nomination of Powell suggests that a sharp hawkish tilt might not be on the cards, the consultancy says.
- Next week’s Fed speakers includes 2017 voters Harker (13/Nov), Evans (14/Nov and 15/Nov) and Kaplan (16/Nov), while 2018 voters Bostic (14/Nov) and Williams (16/Nov), as well as the outgoing Fed Chair Yellen (14/Nov) are also on the slate.
EUROPEAN CENTRAL BANK
- Despite two weeks of gains for the Euro currency, it still remains lower than the level it was both pre- and post- the ECB’s policy meeting a fortnight ago, which will likely please President Draghi, particularly since it is still below the 1.18 rate the ECB has assumed for 2017 (in its latest staff economic projections).
- The central bank’s most recent economic bulletin released this week revealed insight into the potential strategy the ECB might use in tapering its asset purchases, with officials noting that EUR has a role to play in its policy functions. The central bank noted how the EUR’s rise over summer had sapped price pressures, and also noted how the exchange rate is taken into account when considering how asset purchases are calibrated:
- The central bank wrote: "The size and duration of asset purchases are calibrated to deliver a constellation of yields and thus, indirectly, financing conditions that are consistent with achieving the ECB’s inflation aim. Taking into account the endogenous adjustment of the whole spectrum of market conditions, including bank lending rates, corporate bonds and mortgages, as well as the euro exchange rate, the calibration of the APP is aimed at providing the necessary amount of stimulus to the economy to support inflation developments in line with the ECB’s definition of price stability."
- Analysts at ING make the case that the phrase ‘endogenous’ implies the central bank is tracking financial conditions, and if markets front-run the central bank’s reaction function, it will scale back any tightening. ING has says that, accordingly, the central bank is unlikely to be concerned with the level of the EUR while it is knocking beneath 1.20.
- And despite the fact that the EUR has retreated from levels just shy of 1.21 since the middle of September, there is a potent cocktail of forces that could propel the EUR higher, according to Societe Generale: “Confirmation that the ECB will still be buying bonds this time next year, substantial long positions, and a 199bp 10year Treasury/ Bund spread can stall the euro rally for a while yet, but the foundations are still being laid for a move to 1.30 and beyond.”
BANK OF ENGLAND
- According to the BOE’s November forecasts, UK inflation will peak at 3.2% in October, when data is released next week. It is then projected to ease back towards the central bank’s target, eventually hitting that level just after the BOE’s forecast horizon extending to Q4 2020.
- Analysts at Wells Fargo write “look for the CPI inflation rate in the United Kingdom to slowly recede toward the two percent inflation target in the quarters ahead as the price-lifting effects of sterling depreciation fade,” Wells Fargo says, “if, as we expect, the economy continues to grow, then we believe that the MPC will feel confident enough to raise rates again next summer.”
- However, the Brexit uncertainties present downside risks to this view, Wells Fargo says. While it is problematic to predict these outcomes, “if these uncertainties cause businesses to retrench via lower investment and/or cuts to payrolls, the British economy could weaken further. In that event, prospects for further monetary tightening in the United Kingdom would fade,” Wells says.
BANK OF JAPAN
- Despite the easing back of Japanese stocks this week, we did see the Nikkei 225 index hit the highest levels since 1992 as investors took encouragement from the election victory of Shinzo Abe. “The re-election of PM Abe with a super-majority ensures maximum policy continuity and should bolster support for the BoJ's current leadership and accommodative policies,” UBS says, “As a result, BoJ policy is unlikely to move the needle for USD/JPY.”
- UBS notes that current board members have tied the policy of yield curve control to a meaningful upside shift in inflation pressures; “while this may happen as core inflation could push back up above 1% around April next year, the Bank's overall policy stance would likely remain very accommodative given the pledge for a sustained 2% overshoot in CPI,” UBS believes.
- This week, BOJ Governor Kuroda – who is facing some competition in his endeavours to be re-appointed as BOJ chief from Japan PM Adviser Honda – again reiterated his view that the BOJ is willing to allow an inflation overshoot. We’ll leave the jokes aside about how the BOJ has not successfully managed to sustainably meet its inflation goal in the Abenomics era, let alone overshoot it.
- Perhaps the BOJ needs more help from fiscal authorities? That is certainly the view of PM Adviser Honda, who this week suggested that the BOJ and the government should share the objective of targeting nominal output at a level of 600trln yen. Honda was scathing in his assessment of Kuroda’s progress, arguing the incumbent governor shouldn’t be reappointed given his failure to reach the central bank’s inflation objective, and pledged that his approach would be what is necessary to ‘defeat deflation’.
SWISS NATIONAL BANK
- A soft inflation environment will do nothing to suggest that the SNB is anywhere near to a hiking cycle. Headline CPI missed targets, and even though core inflation rose to the highest since March 2011, at 0.50%, it isn’t presenting any firm threat of price pressures.
- “In recent months inflation has been boosted by rising imported inflation, reflecting the franc’s depreciation earlier this year,” Capital Economics writes. “However, this effect is likely to reverse next year as the franc stabilises against the euro. Meanwhile, the continued weakness of wage growth suggests that there is no end in sight to the prolonged period of extraordinarily low domestic price pressures.” And as a result, the consultancy believes that the SNB will remain with its ultra-dovish stance, leaving little scope to lift rates before 2020.
- That approach was reflected in comments from the SNB President Jordan this week, where he repeated his familiar phrases about the “highly valued” franc, and how negative rates are still required.
BANK OF CANADA
- Before the next BOC meeting on 6 December, there are two BOC speakers scheduled to speak; on 15 November, Deputy Governor Wilkins will speak about monetary policy uncertainty, and on 28 November, Governor Poloz will speak (with Wilkins too) at the BOC’s release of the Financial System Review Report.
- Scotiabank’s analysts note that at the previous financial System Review in June, Poloz deferred a question on rate policy to the July MPR, but in the days that followed, Wilkins delivered her now infamous speech where she introduced a tightening bias into the BOC’s policy, in what Scotia describes as “a speech that was likely in the works long before the weekend BIS meetings, the Friday jobs report and the Financial System Review.”
- “As for any residual belief in a BOC rate hike in December or arguably January, Governor Poloz’s recent French language interviews downplayed them,” Scotiabank writes. In an interview with Les Affaires, Poloz said “we increased the key rate twice in the last fifteen weeks (July and September decisions). We now take the time to understand the reaction of the economy,” and Scotiabank does not believe that such an understanding will be achieved with only an additional month or two worth of data.
RESERVE BANK OF AUSTRALIA
- The RBA held its Cash Rate at 1.50%, as was widely expected by analysts, and its growth outlook was largely unchanged. It noted that the labour market continues to improve in spite of the sluggish wage growth. There were no adjustments to its language on the Australian dollar. Elsewhere, the central bank voiced some concerns on household debt.
- Inflation is “likely to remain low for some time”, the RBA said, though it expects price pressures to pick-up gradually as the economy strengthens. The latest SOMP report saw the inflation profile lowered reflecting the reweighting, now forecasting that inflation will return to 2% in 2019.
- “Despite the recent weak retail sales numbers, the low Q3 CPI print and the ABS announcement that the re-benchmarking of the CPI, the RBA continues to see things as remaining on track. It seems that the RBA has been reassured by the improving global economy and tightening local labour market,” says HSBC’s RBA watcher Paul Bloxham, and “as the RBA Governor stated at the parliamentary testimony, back in August, it is a 'reasonable assumption' that 'the next move will be up rather than down' but that 'it's quite some time away if things play out as we expect'. Nothing since then appears to have pushed this view off track.”
RESERVE BANK OF NEW ZEALAND
- At its latest policy meeting, the RBNZ held its OCR at 1.75% as was expected, and though it kept its tone broadly ‘neutral’, there was a distinct cautious tone, and it also added in a few hawkish tweaks.
- “The RBNZ acknowledged the weak housing market, surprisingly slow construction activity, and weak economic activity data of late,” Westpac says, “but these downsides were offset by the lower exchange rate and the outlook for significant fiscal stimulus.” The bank believes that the RBNZ growth forecasts are too optimistic: “The RBNZ is forecasting 3.6% annual GDP growth in 2018, whereas we expect 2.5%. If our GDP view is correct, the RBNZ will become more dovish in 2018. We remain very comfortable forecasting no hike in the OCR until late 2019.”
- Which brings us to the hawkish elements of the report; the central bank said that the new government’s policy presented some uncertainties and policy may have to be adjusted accordingly, but Governor Spencer said in his press conference that the policies may add around 0.5% to GDP growth. Additionally, in its updated forecasts, the RBNZ brought forward its estimation of when it expects to begin hiking rates to Q2 2019, from Q3 2019.
- Elsewhere, some analysts noted that the central bank doesn’t seem to be talking-down the NZD as much. CBA’s economists note that previously, the RBNZ warned that “a lower New Zealand dollar is needed to increase tradables inflation and help deliver more balanced growth”, whereas now, it highlights New Zealand dollar weakness “if sustained, will increase tradables inflation and promote more balanced growth,” dropping the word ‘needed’. And CBA adds that “second, the RBNZ brought forward the timing of when they expect inflation to reach 2% by nine months largely because of a lower trade-weighted index. The RBNZ now projects headline CPI inflation to reach 2% (the midpoint of the RBNZ's 1-3% target band) by Q2 2018 (previously: Q1 2019),” adding that “this can lead to an upward revision to New Zealand interest rate expectations in favour of NZD.”
NORGES BANK
- The latest batch of inflation data out of Norway missed expectations, though there was some small upside in the core metric.
- The NOK hasn’t been mirroring the relentless drive higher in oil prices, as of late, with the trade weighted index down around 2.5% from September while oil has been surging to fresh two-year highs, the latter driven by geopolitical tensions. If the trend continues, HSBC believes that it may be enough for the Norges Bank to revise its inflation forecasts slightly higher.
RIKSBANK
- The main takeaway from the central bank’s latest meeting minutes – where policy and forward guidance was maintained – was policymakers welcoming that inflation was close to target, and stressing that undershooting their inflation target was worse than overshooting it.
- On the horizon, the main question is whether the central bank will extend its asset purchase programme at the December meeting. The consensus is of the opinion that the Riksbank will opt for an extension, given that the ECB’s asset purchase programme will run at a minimum through to next September, before likely being tapered. “So far Governor Ingves has been the biggest dove on the board, and desperately wants to avoid the krona from appreciating too strongly if Riksbank’s monetary policy deviates too notably from that of the ECB,” Commerzbank writes. “Cecilia Skingsley stressed that Riksbank was not a ‘caravan’ in relation to ECB policy and that a positive environment - i.e. inflation at target - would allow some deviation from ECB policy.” Additionally, Martin Floden seems to be comfortable with the progress inflation has been making.
- “These comments at least point towards these two board members voting in favour of an end of the asset purchases in December, in particular as EURSEK level above 9.70 no doubt provide scope to allow some krona appreciation,” Comemrzbank says.
Free. No signup, no card.
Use the Platform